|
Back to Basics
Alternative
Quantitative Methods for Screening Penetrant Testing Cleaning Solutions
Tables
Table
1 - Results of various cleaning solutions with Method D FPI: measurements
given in lm/m2 (lm/yd2)
|
|
S1
|
S2
|
S3
|
TAM1-1
|
TAM1-2
|
TAM1-3
|
TAM1-4
|
TAM1-5
|
TAM2-1
|
TAM2-2
|
TAM2-3
|
TAM2-4
|
TAM2-5
|
|
Control
|
6.67
|
34.88
|
36.06
|
97.52
|
6.14
|
3.23
|
1.83
|
0.43
|
18.41
|
2.26
|
4.84
|
3.01
|
2.15
|
|
|
(5.58)
|
(29.16)
|
(30.15)
|
(81.53)
|
(5.13)
|
(2.70)
|
(1.53)
|
(0.36)
|
(15.39)
|
(1.89)
|
(4.05)
|
(2.52)
|
(1.80)
|
|
Cleaner
1
|
5.17
|
55.33
|
21.20
|
31.54
|
5.49
|
1.51
|
1.83
|
NR
|
31.22
|
6.03
|
1.94
|
1.83
|
4.74
|
|
|
(4.32)
|
(46.26)
|
(17.72)
|
(26.37)
|
(4.59)
|
(1.26)
|
(1.53)
|
(NR)
|
(26.10)
|
(5.04)
|
(1.62)
|
(1.53)
|
(3.96)
|
|
Cleaner
2
|
13.56
|
34.23
|
17.76
|
26.91
|
3.66
|
1.94
|
0.86
|
0.65
|
12.81
|
5.49
|
1.61
|
1.72
|
NR
|
|
|
(11.34)
|
(28.62)
|
(14.85)
|
(22.50)
|
(3.06)
|
(1.62)
|
(0.72)
|
(0.54)
|
(10.71)
|
(4.59)
|
(1.35)
|
(1.44)
|
(NR)
|
|
Cleaner
3
|
6.35
|
38.43
|
7.10
|
4.95*
|
2.69*
|
1.51*
|
3.12*
|
1.61*
|
3.55*
|
2.15*
|
1.83*
|
1.29*
|
1.29*
|
|
|
(5.31)
|
(32.13)
|
(5.94)
|
(4.14)*
|
(2.25)*
|
(1.26)*
|
(2.61)*
|
(1.35)*
|
(2.97)*
|
(1.80)*
|
(1.53)*
|
(1.08)*
|
(1.08)*
|
|
Cleaner
4
|
5.60
|
526.89
|
52.64
|
77.50
|
5.38
|
5.27
|
3.23
|
4.31
|
200.21
|
9.69
|
7.10
|
9.80
|
5.06
|
|
|
(4.68)
|
(440.48)
|
(44.01)
|
(64.79)
|
(4.50)
|
(4.41)
|
(2.70)
|
(3.60)
|
(167.38)
|
(8.10)
|
(5.94)
|
(8.19)
|
(4.23)
|
|
Cleaner
5
|
1.29
|
254.03
|
14.42
|
7.00*
|
5.38*
|
3.44
|
3.44*
|
9.47*
|
8.93*
|
7.97*
|
5.92*
|
11.19*
|
9.90*
|
|
|
(1.08)
|
(212.37)
|
(12.06)
|
(5.85)*
|
(4.50)*
|
(2.88)
|
(2.88)*
|
(7.92)*
|
(7.47)*
|
(6.66)*
|
(4.95)*
|
(9.35)*
|
(8.28)*
|
|
Cleaner
6
|
19.38
|
119.69
|
44.56
|
1.94*
|
4.52*
|
2.91
|
3.12*
|
3.66*
|
14.53*
|
12.16*
|
6.89*
|
5.70*
|
5.49*
|
|
|
(16.20)
|
(100.06)
|
(37.25)
|
(1.62)*
|
(3.78)*
|
(2.43)
|
(2.61)*
|
(3.06)*
|
(12.15)*
|
(10.17)*
|
(5.76)*
|
(4.77)*
|
(4.59)*
|
| |